Some Security Devices Just Aren't that Secure

By Steve Anderson December 11, 2012

Network security is high on a lot of people's lists these days. Keeping computers safe from attacks, keeping networks safe from attacks, and keeping the information contained therein from slipping out and being misused is a major priority. But according to a new report released today from Broadband-Testing, not every security device may be as powerful as their competitors on store shelves.

Broadband-Testing's report covered the results of performance testing for a set of four network firewall solutions on the market from Cisco Systems, WatchGuard, NetPilot, SonicWall and others. Broadband-Testing used the Spirent security suite to test out the devices, and established benchmarks for the devices, focusing on things like application traffic performance and network traffic performance both with and without attacks. The results produced some unexpected information, and will make anyone looking at new hardware for network security look twice.


Image via Shutterstock

What Broadband-Testing discovered was that, when any IT network firewall solution is stepped up to enable advanced functions like IDS / IPS functionality, there's a concomitant loss of performance in virtually every device tested. What this in particular means is that, whenever a device is selected for security, it needs to be tested, in that system, to ensure that it will actually do the job it sets out to do. But aside from that, basic firewall protection was sound, and most firewall products will actually do at least reasonably close to what they claim they will do. However, the other clear takeaway from Broadband-Testing's evaluation was that testing was especially important, given that the products involved in the testing had inherent differences that directly affected their ability to fight threats.

The founder and director of Broadband-Testing, Steve Broadhead, further elaborated on the key point about testing the claims of manufacturers in the field, saying, “Enterprises have much to lose by not taking the initiative to create and enforce a strict security regime. Instead they depend only on their security device vendors’ claims to assess the fortification of their network. The goal of this test was to look at different firewall solutions that sit at various price points and evaluate them on pure performance. Spirent’s solutions were instrumental in the testing, and were able to push the four products with realistic and scaling performance traffic and threat traffic. By testing the performance of the security devices and verifying against vendor claims, it was easy to identify areas of weakness in the network.”

Indeed, it's never a good idea to take any claims at face value—Ronald Reagan actually made the famous assessment, “Trust but verify”, which still serves as good advice today—but rather be prepared to independently assess their veracity before relying on them to provide the security that's all too necessary in the current environment.

Protecting systems from attack not only keeps those vital systems up and running, and providing their benefits to the larger body, but also prevents disastrous PR troubles like those Sony was faced with following the attack on the PlayStation Network. No system is fool-proof, of course, but being proactive and doing everything available to protect information will go a long way toward not only preventing the worst of the attacks on the network, but also preventing the worst of the attacks on the company itself in the event that something should go wrong. 




Edited by Brooke Neuman

Contributing TechZone360 Writer

SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Related Articles

Looking For The Next iPod/Echo

By: Rob Enderle    4/29/2016

The Amazon Echo, not the Apple Watch, became the last iPod-like product largely because of a far more accessible price point, a more compelling name, …

Read More

Apple Needs Reset, Not Elon Musk

By: Doug Mohney    4/29/2016

Apple's 13 percent sales decline and subsequent stock price drop this week has lead to the usual crazy talk about how to "fix" the company. Vivek Wadh…

Read More

Is the Apple Bubble Finally Bursting?

By: Andrew Bindelglass    4/28/2016

Over the past 13 years, Apple has been one of the most successful companies in the world of tech, posting sales growths in 51 straight quarters. That …

Read More

Shared-Space Providers (Airbnb) Poised to Beat Ride-Sharers (Uber)

By: Steve Anderson    4/28/2016

Travel may be starting to make a bit of a comeback, as a new report suggests that shared-space providers like Airbnb and WeWork are on the rise.

Read More

Facebook Wants More Sharing, Building New Camera App to Drive It

By: Steve Anderson    4/28/2016

One of the great downsides to having a lot of content in any one place is that, after a while, it starts looking downright pointless to add more.

Read More