Pirates Beware: British Courts Go Cyber Hunting with New ISP-Level Blocks

By Steve Anderson February 28, 2013

While the British navy was one of the biggest headaches for real-world piracy back in its heyday, media pirates these days are getting trouble from a different British institution: the British court system. The U.K.'s High Court has recently ordered ISPs in the country to block three more websites connected with piracy – H33T, Fenopy and Kickass Torrents.

These three sites in particular were targeted, according to the British Phonographic Industry (BPI), as they engaged in copyright infringement on a "significant scale." The High Court, seeming to agree that this was the case, demanded that the ISPs shut down users' access to those websites.

On one end of the spectrum, groups like the BPI claim its approach of rampant banning of anything that smacks too hard of infringement has had some effect. A recent NPD report showed that there were some substantial declines in users illegally downloading music, instead turning to legal, easy-to-use services like Spotify.

This led Geoff Taylor, chief executive of the BPI, to say, "The growth of digital music in the UK is held back by a raft of illegal businesses commercially exploiting music online without permission. Blocking illegal sites helps ensure that the legal digital market can grow and labels can continue to sign and develop new talent."

However, there was a quick rebuttal from, not surprisingly, the leader of the U.K.'s Pirate Party, Loz Kaye, who called the BPI "out of control," asserting further that, "The U.K. has now handed the power over what we see on the Internet to corporate lobbyists."

Kaye had some numbers to back up the rhetoric, saying that the 2012 sales figures showed that blocking access to sites like the Pirate Bay didn't exactly help the music industry. Moreover, the BBC itself had a bit of data showing that blocking actions like those recently undertaken only had value in the short term, and levels of peer-to-peer sharing didn't take long to recover to their more normal levels.

It's something of a truism online that, what one effort can block, another can work around. Indeed, it doesn't often take long for these blocked sites to slightly change their Web presence and reemerge elsewhere, unaffected by a court ruling. That doesn't help the perspective of places like the BPI, who'd rather see that no one ever download anything ever again. But it certainly seems to be the case, and that's the kind of environment that these court rulings and such must operate within.

The realities of the Internet often prevent complete piracy protection, and that means other methods are required.

The idea of an Internet without piracy, on at least some level, just likely isn't achievable. Still, offering easy-to-use, inexpensive and hassle-free alternatives will go a long way in keeping piracy to a minimum.

Ensuring that the content people want can be had easily, inexpensively and safely will never go unappreciated – or unused.

Edited by Braden Becker

Contributing TechZone360 Writer

Related Articles

DDoS Attack Causes Several Site Outages

By: Alicia Young    10/21/2016

This morning, as thousands of people woke up and started their daily routines, they found that it had been disrupted. Those who like to lie in bed scr…

Read More

Death by Hedge Funds: Why Samsung is Run by Idiots and They Aren't Alone

By: Rob Enderle    10/12/2016

Samsung is certainly having a bad quarter. First their halo product the Samsung Galaxy Note 7 starts blowing up or catching fire and they attempted th…

Read More

Addressing the Third Party Threat: Five Financial Industry Takeaways from the SWIFT Hack

By: Special Guest    10/12/2016

It has now been several months since more than a dozen financial institutions associated with the Society for a Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecomm…

Read More

The Impact of Virtual Reality's Mainstream Evolution

By: Special Guest    10/12/2016

As virtual reality becomes more prevalent in both a business and personal setting, less expensive equipment is becoming more obtainable. This increase…

Read More

Google's Losing Temperament Won't Help With Phones

By: Doug Mohney    10/11/2016

For all of Google's strength in search and huge amounts of cash, it really has struggled to be a success beyond its core business. Last week's release…

Read More