FCC: Operators Should Keep CALM and Carry On

By Tara Seals June 05, 2014

Remember when TV commercials seemed to always be louder than the programming that they ran with? It wasn’t just the imagination at work—typically they were, and it was a consumer dissatisfaction trigger for many. The FCC’s Commercial Advertisement Loudness Mitigation (CALM) Act is meant to eliminate the issue—but hasn’t completely. Now, the Commission has approved a technical change that could further reduce the volume of the ads.

On December 15, 2010, President Obama signed the Act, mandating that TV commercials aren't allowed to be any louder on average than the shows they accompany. It went into effect on Dec. 13, 2012, and requires that all multichannel video operators, not just cable companies, adopt a set of recommended practice provisions.

This week, the FCC has approved an improved loudness measurement algorithm that closes a sneaky loophole for advertisers and their distribution partners. The new standard was developed by the Advanced Television Systems Committee(ATSC) and is designed to keep advertisers from using silence to offset excessive loudness in calculating the average volume of a commercial. “It employs ‘gating’ that will exclude very quiet or silent passages of a commercial when calculating the average loudness of that commercial,” the Commission said in its Notice of Proposed Rulemaking last November. It added that “use of the new algorithm may result in some reduction in commercial loudness in certain circumstances.”

Operators and broadcasters have a year to comply with the new standard—a caveat that the National Association of Broadcasters requested and has received.

The way CALM is implemented has to do with audio signatures. Essentially, they have to follow a golden rule, which says that the loudness of the programming equals the dial norm value—which is a data value transmitted with most U.S. broadcasts. This is used to adjust, automatically, how loudly the system plays back the content. So, the loudness of the content must equal the dial norm value. Pay-TV providers must be prepared to demonstrate compliance, and to provide spot-check information, otherwise facing potential FCC fines from enforcement actions, not to mentioncustomer dissatisfaction and churn.

Though the implementation deadline for the new algorithm is June 4, 2015, industry folks can adopt the standard early if they choose. There are, however, notable operational challenges that TV providers have on their plate when it comes to complying with CALM, stemming from the increasingly complex landscape of video delivery. For instance, they need to implement a monitoring and quality assurance system, or set of processes, to allow them to provide compliance information to the FCC, as well as take automated and rapid correction when there’s an issue to avoid customer complaints. It sounds simple, but is actually quite a complex operational task when faced with multiscreen-driven multiple types of access devices and content delivery infrastructure.

Operators would do well to get on the stick though, because customers will indeed churn. In all, as of the beginning of the year, the FCC has received more than 20,000 complaints since the rules took effect in late 2012. Of those, more than 14,500 were referred to the commission’s enforcement bureau.

The rate of complaints is decreasing however. In January 2013, the FCC received 4,405 complaints for commercial loudness, according to a Commission report. By the end of last year, the number had dropped to 656.

“There continues to be a general downward trend in complaints related to loud commercials since December 2012,” the head of FCC’s enforcement bureau, P. Michele Ellison, wrote in the report.




Edited by Allison Sansone

TechZone360 Contributor

SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Related Articles

What If You Could Speak to a Holocaust Survivor? Now You Can

By: Alicia Young    4/28/2017

The USC Shoah Foundation was founded by Steven Spielberg in 1994 to document first-hand accounts of the Holocaust for future generations. Since then, …

Read More

Russian Hacker Receives Record-Breaking Prison Sentence

By: Alicia Young    4/27/2017

Roman Valeryevich Seleznev was sentenced to 27 years in prison last week in the U.S. for stealing millions of credit card details from businesses.

Read More

Microsoft Brings New Talent to LinkedIn, Dynamics 365

By: Steve Anderson    4/27/2017

Microsoft gunning for a place in the human capital management sphere with new application, and the addition of Dynamics 365 to LinkedIn.

Read More

Four Tips for Untouchable Intellectual Property

By: Anna Johansson    4/26/2017

Intellectual property is considered an intangible asset and can include things like recipe ingredients, articles, logos, and proprietary systems and p…

Read More

Is it Time for Someone to Clean Slate a Gaming Console?

By: Rob Enderle    4/24/2017

I've been looking at a lot of the comments on game review articles and forums of late, and gamers appear to be disappointed that the games aren't gett…

Read More