Did Microsoft's Antitrust Agreement Create a More Competitive Market?

By

The antitrust settlement agreement that Microsoft signed with the Department of Justice expires today, nearly nine years after it went into effect. But the question still remains, how much impact did the historic oversight have on the technology world?

The skirmish began more than a decade ago when the DOJ, the District of Columbia and 19 separate states sued Microsoft for a "broad pattern of anti-competitive conduct," including using its Windows OS monopoly to discourage PC makers from promoting Web browsers and middleware that would compete with Internet Explorer.

Following a few years in the courts, Microsoft agreed to sign a consent decree that barred it from penalizing PC makers when they included technology from other software browsers. The settlement also mandated that Microsoft disclose its middleware interfaces and other technical data to third party software developers, among other stipulations. Over the last nine years, Microsoft has had to demonstrate to the DOJ that it is no longer indulging in antitrust practices.

With that oversight period ending today, the DOJ has come out to take credit for the positive market changes that the ruling has prompted.

"Nearly every desktop middleware market, from web browsers to media players to instant messaging software, is more competitive today than it was when the final judgment was entered," the DOJ said in a statement. "In addition, the final judgment helped create competitive conditions that enabled new kinds of products, such as cloud computing services and mobile devices, to develop as potential platform threats to the Windows desktop operating system."

Most analysts agree that a competitive balance has been created, but not because of the consent decree. Yes, Internet Explorer is no longer as dominant as it used to be. IE's market share dropped from 95 percent in 2002, to just over 55 percent as of this April. However, the majority of analysts believe that the transition was due to sweeping market changes, not regulatory ones, says Jay Greene at CNET.

"It'd be wrong to suggest that the consent decree played a meaningful role in that shift," Greene writes. "The widespread adoption of broadband data connections meant users could download browser software quickly, rather than having to wait minutes or even hours to get something that competed with Internet Explorer."

Greene added that Microsoft's failure to innovate alongside Google and Mozilla also led to its slip in market share.

As for the PC OS market, the consent decree did little to change the playing field. Microsoft's Windows operating system accounted for 93 percent of the desktop market in 2002. The company's market share now stands at 91 percent, according to IDC.

Beecher Tuttle is a TechZone360 contributor. He has extensive experience writing and editing for print publications and online news websites. He has specialized in a variety of industries, including health care technology, politics and education. To read more of his articles, please visit his columnist page.

Edited by Jamie Epstein

Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. [Free eNews Subscription]

TechZone360 Contributor

SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Related Articles

Enhancing Cybersecurity Measures for Modern Businesses

By: Contributing Writer    7/2/2025

Cyberattacks are rising, and businesses of all sizes feel the pressure. Small companies often think they're too small to be targets. They aren't. Hack…

Read More

Lessons Learned from Enterprise Oracle Cloud Migrations

By: Contributing Writer    7/1/2025

Switching to Oracle Cloud can feel daunting. Security risks, unexpected expenses, and performance troubles often turn what seems like an effortless up…

Read More

Protecting Business Assets with Smarter Security Frameworks

By: Contributing Writer    7/1/2025

Protecting your business is more challenging than ever. Cyber threats are increasing every day. Hackers target small and large businesses alike, searc…

Read More

Emerging Trends in Technology and Their Impact on Future Innovations

By: Contributing Writer    7/1/2025

Technology is changing faster than ever. Business owners often struggle to keep up. What's trending today might be outdated tomorrow. Falling behind c…

Read More

Tech Podcast Award Winners Bring Excitement and Enthusiasm to a Range of Important Tech Topics

By: TMCnet Staff    6/18/2025

Tech Podcast Award winners produce engaging, informative, and often entertaining content, bringing valuable insight from industry front lines to the e…

Read More