Some Revenue Sources are Hardly Worth the Effort

By

Some things in life are hard to understand. How firms that worry about their brands can allow “cramming” to occur is one of those things.  

AT&T Mobility has agreed to settle allegations that it charged mobile customers without their permission for third-party services like ringtones, wallpapers, and text message subscriptions for horoscopes, flirting tips, and celebrity gossip.

Current and former AT&T customers who paid for unauthorized third-party charges after January 1, 2009 may apply for refunds.

AT&T isn’t alone. T-Mobile US was fined by the FTC as well. Verizon settled a cramming case as well.  

The problem has been addressed for consumers using the fixed networks  as well.

The Federal Communications Commission has estimated that consumer fraud could represent as much as $10 billion in consumer fraud over five years.

Whether the amount of fraudulent charges are hundreds of millions a year or more is less the issue than the sheer reputational harm to service providers, one might argue.

Granted, third party billed apps and services represent a desired source of potential revenue for the mobile carriers. But the amount of fraud is the downside.

As often is the case, billing is the culprit. Granted, it is a devilish business, billing. Billing records are notoriously hard to understand, under the best of circumstances, especially in the mobile realm, where shared and family accounts increase the sheer amount of detail covering multiple services, devices and users.

As one example, the  operators of an Atlanta-based company have agreed to settle Federal Trade Commission allegations that they crammed charges on consumers’ cell phone bills without their consent, causing more than $10 million in consumer injury.

The two settlements, with Wise Media and its CEO, Brian M. Buckley, and Winston J. Deloney, permanently ban them from placing any charges on consumers’ telephone bills or assisting anyone else in doing so.

The settlements also prohibit them from using any other method to charge consumers for goods or services without ensuring that they are aware of the terms of the purchase and have expressly agreed to be charged.

“This case involved a new delivery system for an old-fashioned scam,” said Jessica Rich, Director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection. “Getting consumers’ consent before charging them is as basic a consumer protection as you’ll find, whether you’re dealing with a brick and mortar store or with a mobile payment provider.

Third-party billing is a service telcos like. But it seems to lead to fraudster activity.

The reputational damage does not seem worth it.




Edited by Stefania Viscusi
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. [Free eNews Subscription]

Contributing Editor

SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Related Articles

Enhancing Cybersecurity Measures for Modern Businesses

By: Contributing Writer    7/2/2025

Cyberattacks are rising, and businesses of all sizes feel the pressure. Small companies often think they're too small to be targets. They aren't. Hack…

Read More

Lessons Learned from Enterprise Oracle Cloud Migrations

By: Contributing Writer    7/1/2025

Switching to Oracle Cloud can feel daunting. Security risks, unexpected expenses, and performance troubles often turn what seems like an effortless up…

Read More

Protecting Business Assets with Smarter Security Frameworks

By: Contributing Writer    7/1/2025

Protecting your business is more challenging than ever. Cyber threats are increasing every day. Hackers target small and large businesses alike, searc…

Read More

Emerging Trends in Technology and Their Impact on Future Innovations

By: Contributing Writer    7/1/2025

Technology is changing faster than ever. Business owners often struggle to keep up. What's trending today might be outdated tomorrow. Falling behind c…

Read More

Tech Podcast Award Winners Bring Excitement and Enthusiasm to a Range of Important Tech Topics

By: TMCnet Staff    6/18/2025

Tech Podcast Award winners produce engaging, informative, and often entertaining content, bringing valuable insight from industry front lines to the e…

Read More