Apple Challenging $625.5 Million Verdict

By

Mirror Worlds is hoping to take a bite out of Apple with a lawsuit that could make the multinational giant liable for $625.5 million.

A jury in Texas has ordered Apple to pay the staggering amount for violating three patents owned by Mirror Worlds, a firm founded by David Gelernter, a Yale University computer science professor.

But Apple isn’t taking the news lying down. The company is challenging the verdict from the federal court in Tyler, Texas, saying the court has not yet looked at some of its counterclaims. In an emergency motion, Apple has asked the court to stay the decision until a formal decision is handed down.

The patents in dispute relate to Mirror Worlds’ “Document Stream Operating System,” where documents are stored in “one or more chronologically ordered streams,” according to documents filed in the case. The patents overlap with Mac features such as Cover Flow, which allows users to skim through the cover art of MP3 files as if they were pages in a book. Another overlapping characteristic is Time Machine, which performs automatic backups.

The court found Apple liable for both accidental and willful infringement on three patents owned by Mirror Worlds. According to Bloomberg News, the $625.5 million award is the second-biggest jury verdict in 2010, and the fourth-biggest patent verdict in U.S. history. The largest this year, for $677 million against nursing home company Skilled Healthcare Group, later settled for $50 million.

Tyler, Texas is no stranger to patent disputes. The town, known for its speedy trials, has been widely criticized for a perceived bias towards plaintiffs in patent infringement lawsuits, including patent trolls who specifically acquire patents in order to seek payment for companies they claim are infringing on those patents. In fact, in 2003, there were 14 patent cases filed in Tyler. By 2004, the number more than quadrupled to 59 patent cases filed. In 2006, the number of cases skyrocketed to an estimated 236.




Edited by Stefanie Mosca
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. [Free eNews Subscription]

TechZone360 Contributing Editor

SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Related Articles

ChatGPT Isn't Really AI: Here's Why

By: Contributing Writer    4/17/2024

ChatGPT is the biggest talking point in the world of AI, but is it actually artificial intelligence? Click here to find out the truth behind ChatGPT.

Read More

Revolutionizing Home Energy Management: The Partnership of Hub Controls and Four Square/TRE

By: Reece Loftus    4/16/2024

Through a recently announced partnership with manufacturer Four Square/TRE, Hub Controls is set to redefine the landscape of home energy management in…

Read More

4 Benefits of Time Tracking Software for Small Businesses

By: Contributing Writer    4/16/2024

Time tracking is invaluable for every business's success. It ensures teams and time are well managed. While you can do manual time tracking, it's time…

Read More

How the Terraform Registry Helps DevOps Teams Increase Efficiency

By: Contributing Writer    4/16/2024

A key component to HashiCorp's Terraform infrastructure-as-code (IaC) ecosystem, the Terraform Registry made it to the news in late 2023 when changes …

Read More

Nightmares, No More: New CanineAlert Device for Service Dogs Helps Reduce PTSD for Owners, Particularly Veterans

By: Alex Passett    4/11/2024

Canine Companions, a nonprofit organization that transforms the lives of veterans (and others) suffering PTSD with vigilant service dogs, has debuted …

Read More