Wireless Phone Illness Suit Rejected by SCOTUS

By

A group of Pennsylvania residents hoping to sue mobile phone manufacturers and retailers over illness or risk of illness from the phones has been disappointed – again – this time by the U.S. Supreme Court, which has refused to revive their lawsuit.

The Supreme Court has upheld a federal appeals court decision that said that FCC regulations preclude lawsuits under state laws by mobile phone consumers. It's not a new ruling: most other courts tasked with similar lawsuits have reached similar conclusions, according to Bloomberg. Behind the ruling are 1996 FCC standards covering radio frequency emissions that basically preempt lawsuits.

The original lawsuit, Farina v. Nokia, had named more than a dozen companies and wireless industry trade associations as defendants, the pool of which included Nokia. AT&T's wireless division and Motorola Mobility Holdings Inc. (now owned by Google) and Verizon Wireless (which is jointly owned by Verizon Wireless and Britain's Vodafone).

Two SCOTUS justices – Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justice Stephen Breyer – recused themselves from the case as both disclosed they own shares of Nokia.

The appeal centered on the legal impact of the FCC standards that govern radio frequency emissions and require pre- authorization of phones sold or leased in the country. The Philadelphia-based 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said those rules, first adopted in 1996, preempt any additional requirements under state law, including those imposed through lawsuits.

The Obama administration went on record urging the Supreme Court to reject the appeal.



Tracey Schelmetic is a contributing editor for TechZone360. To read more of Tracey's articles, please visit her columnist page.

Edited by Jennifer Russell
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. [Free eNews Subscription]

TechZone360 Contributor

SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Related Articles

Why More Leads Won't Fix a Broken Lead Management Process

By: Contributing Writer    6/23/2026

When sales results start to stall, many organizations immediately look to the top of the funnel for answers. The assumption is simple: if revenue i…

Read More

Your Post-Quantum Readiness Starts at Y2Q Summit

By: TMCnet News    5/27/2026

Y2Q Summit is an executive conference focused on helping enterprises prepare for the coming era of quantum computing disruption, cybersecurity transfo…

Read More

Why Award Marketing Should Be Part of Every B2B Tech Company's Growth Strategy

By: Erik Linask    5/20/2026

Award marketing matters for B2B tech companies because industry recognition can strengthen trust, support sales and partner relationships, improve con…

Read More

Why Email Is Still the Most Underrated Layer of Modern Software Infrastructure

By: Contributing Writer    5/15/2026

Take, for example, the following scenario. A user requests a password reset, waits a few seconds, refreshes their inbox and nothing arrives. They try …

Read More

Jitterbit's Visionary Status Signals a Shift in the iPaaS Market

By: Contributing Writer    4/7/2026

As enterprise ecosystems grow more complex, integration has become less of a backend IT function and more of a strategic driver of business performanc…

Read More